I’ve really put a lot of thought into the aftermath of the America’s Inspirational Miss Pageant held last weekend in Maumee, Ohio. This was the only pageant I’ve ever pulled a contestant out of in ALL my pageant career. First let me start off with this....my granddaughter won every single optional during the awards banquet on Saturday evening, the only contestant in the pageant to do so. Based on that, we could have just ignored the issues and plowed through with fun fashion and evening g Show more
I’ve really put a lot of thought into the aftermath of the America’s Inspirational Miss Pageant held last weekend in Maumee, Ohio. This was the only pageant I’ve ever pulled a contestant out of in ALL my pageant career. First let me start off with this....my granddaughter won every single optional during the awards banquet on Saturday evening, the only contestant in the pageant to do so. Based on that, we could have just ignored the issues and plowed through with fun fashion and evening gown on Sunday, but there comes a time when a crown is just not worth it. This was definitely that time. Allowing the staff, and the one judge to treat me, as well as our team in the manner they did is definitely not something I could stand by and allow. I’m very competitive and love the thrill of a win, but winning, after being treated poorly really doesn’t feel like a win. I felt sad, even after winning all the optionals on Saturday at the awards banquet, and just wanted to go home. I knew I was there in a professional capacity as well, so I pushed through it.
What bothers me so much, is that many of the contestants and their families appeared to accept the terrible atmosphere as normal, and this saddens me. I told one of the queens mothers yesterday that had AIM been our first pageant experience, it would have also been my last experience. There is just not enough words to describe how awful the weekend was from start to finish. I just want the girls competing to know that this is NOT how other pageants are run. Sure, there are always bad pageants, bad judges, etc. But that is rare. We attend pageants frequently, often 3-4 times per month during normal years. The pageants we go to are fun & fair, provide a safe, and family friendly environment, and care about us.
From a short 3 hour prelim, to a 10 day international pageant, I’ve done them all. I rarely have an issue, even if we go home without a crown. If we enjoyed the pageant, felt it was fairly judged, saw no conflict of interest between staff, judges or contestants, and if the pageant ran the way they advertised, we definitely would go back. You can’t always win, and often losing is just the push you need to improve the next time. And if a pageant isn’t fair, if there is COI, or they don’t give out the prize package promised, I generally check it off my list and don’t do it again. I’ll be honest if you ask me why, but I usually will not go “public” about it because I don’t want the backlash from people who weren’t there, or because I don’t want to hurt the winners feelings. And sometimes others relish in the fun of seeing someone “lose” because they just aren’t nice people.
At AIM there have been several people who did win, who have stepped forward publicly to say that the pageant was as described by my “review” on Facebook. A young queen, who is my client, and a part of our coaching team has not received her prizes. The directors posted that she didn’t get them because she wouldn’t (not didn’t) sign a contract. The contract could have easily been emailed and returned. As we had a 10 hour drive home and the pageant ran late, her mother informed the director she couldn’t stay any longer. The director simply said, no problem. They then ignored her messages, blocked her from social media and posted on their social media that she skipped out. In addition they have lied about a sash being damaged and left behind in the dressing room with a vulgar note. They insinuated that a teen left it, but have not provided proof to this. Why? Because they cannot. And now, on Wednesday, if they did it would clearly be doctored. What was left behind on a table? The AIM Jr Teen NY sash that my granddaughter borrowed because we accidentally forgot hers at home. It was left with exactly two safety pins in it that I used to make it smaller and to close it because it didn’t have Velcro. Why didn’t one of us return it in person? Reach out to me at [email protected], I will gladly describe why we didn’t wish to speak to staff in person again.
The AIM directors have gone on social media in the past few days making accusations, and statements that are untrue. They have deleted negative reviews, turned their pageant social media pages on and off and blocked anyone with a complaint. They are refusing to give a national queen her prizes simply because the parent pointed out the issues she had with their ability to direct a decent pageant and because they just don’t care. They clearly showed they cared about their core group of friends, bending rules in their handbook, or outright breaking rules. I believe they didn’t expect any of us to speak up about their atrocious behavior, how terrible the pageant was, or how unfair it was. When we did we were either completely ignored, blocked on social media, or lied about on social media. It just appears that this group is used to being at terrible pageants so to them it is normal.
Of course you will always get someone to say positive things about a pageant simply because they won, or because they are afraid to speak up due to public backlash, or just because they have never been to a great, fair pageant, and this is “normal” to them. You also have the contestant looking for brownie points, hoping they will do well next time. We don’t do pageants theta require that to win, we do the ones that you win based on merit.
There are so many amazing systems out there. Systems where what is advertised is provided, both in atmosphere and prizes. Systems where directors are honest, and care about the competitor and about future competitors. And systems that are fun, family friend events that you would be proud to represent.
As each day passes, I’m so glad we pulled Shiloh out, it was truly bad enough that even after winning all the optionals we knew it was not a title we would allow her to support or represent. I just hope the directors either learn from their many mistakes and accept the criticism they have received, or hang up their crowns and move on to another journey. I don’t believe they have the real pageant experience to put on a national level title holder pageant, should not expect only certain queens to lock into a year long contract, when they are not enforcing other queens to do so, and should up their prize package if they do wish to continue making this a contract style scholarship pageant.
I’m also incredibly disappointed in the Pageant Planet verification. That verification is NOT earned, it is paid for. Verification by Pageant Planet definitely needs to change to a positive verification AFTER a system can prove they deserve it, not because they simply paid you a fee.Show less