The Miss Maine USA & Miss Maine Teen USA 2005 pageant ended with Erica Commeau winning Miss and Courtney Peterson winning Teen. The two competed in Miss USA and Miss Teen USA!

The Top Five Placements at Miss Maine USA were:
1st Runner-Up: Addie Myrick
2nd Runner-Up: Rebecca Morrell
3rd Runner-Up: Catherine Stringham
4th Runner-Up: Sorassa Soeur

Semi-finalists:
Jessica Allen
Jillian Bryer
Kristina Libby
Christina Lougee
Crystal Martin

Congeniality: Catherine Stringham
Photogenic: Addie Myrick

The Top Five Placements at Miss Maine Teen USA were:
1st Runner-Up: Kaetlin Parent
2nd Runner-Up: Arikka Knights
3rd Runner-Up: Donna Schlieper
4th Runner-Up: Ainsley Lange

Semi-finalists:
Jessica Davis
Aleka Emerson
Payson Benner
Jennifer Barriault
Rachel Southworth
Rebecca Morrell
Britney Mowatt
Melissa Gaudet
Vanessa Gerry
Tara Hadsell

Congeniality: Tiamo Wright
Photogenic: Arikka Knights